Cong-Jhen Lin1, Chuan-Lin Chang2, Chih-Fu Tseng1,3, Hong-Ping Lin 2, Hsing-Cheng Hsi 1

Graduate Institute of Environmental Engineering, National Taiwan University, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
Department of Chemistry, National Cheng-Kung University, Tainan 70101, Taiwan
Taiwan Power Research Institute, Taiwan Power Company, New Taipei City 23847, Taiwan

Received: October 31, 2018
Revised: April 1, 2019
Accepted: May 1, 2019

Download Citation: ||  

  • Download: PDF

Cite this article:

Lin, C.J., Chang, C.L., Tseng, C.F., Lin, H.P. and Hsi, H.C. (2019). Preparation of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce Oxide/Mesoporous Silica via Silicate Exfoliation for Removal of NO and Hg0. Aerosol Air Qual. Res. 19: 1421-1438.


  • Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce silica were prepared via silicate-exfoliation method.
  • Silicate-exfoliation caused large surface area and uniform metal oxide dispersion.
  • Ce promoted NO removal with presence of SO2 by increasing Brønsted acid sites.
  • Oxidation followed by adsorption resulted in Hg0 removal for the tested samples.
  • Adsorbed HCl was the key component responsible for Hg0 oxidation and adsorption.


Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce oxide-incorporated mesoporous silica was formed by hydrothermally exfoliating silicate, and the physicochemical properties and NO/Hg0 removal efficiency were investigated. The exfoliation induced structural reformation, resulting in a large specific surface area and the uniform dispersion of metal oxides on the surface. The transfer of valences between Cu2+ and Mn3+ in the Cu-Mn silica contributed to the single reduction peak displayed in the H2 temperature-programmed reduction profiles and the high Mn4+/Mn and Cu+/Cu ratios observed via X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The high oxygen lability of the Cu-Mn silica may have inhibited its ability to remove NO. By contrast, when SO2 was present, incorporating Ce enhanced the NO removal efficiency due to the increased number of Brønsted acid sites. Hg0 removal tests indicated that adsorption was the primary removal mechanism for both the Cu-Mn and the Cu-Mn-Ce silica samples. Cu2Mn8 exhibited the highest Hg removal efficiency, suggesting that Ce’s enhancing effect on Hg0 adsorption was diminished when a large amount of Mn was present. Of the gaseous components, the adsorbed HCl was mainly responsible for the oxidation and subsequent adsorption of Hg0. Furthermore, with the addition of SO2, the competitive adsorption of SO2 and the resulting HgCl2 did not decrease the Cu-Mn silica’s efficiency in oxidizing Hg0, but the oxidized Hg was less adsorptive.

Keywords: Silicate exfoliation; Coal combustion; Mercury; Multi-pollutant; Metal oxide.


Coal-fired power plants (CFPPs) have been reported as one of the major anthropogenic emission sources of NOx, SO2, and heavy metals, such as mercury (U.S. EPA, 2012; UNEP, 2013). NOx plays a major role in the photochemical reactions in the troposphere and stratosphere, which further cause severe environmental impacts, namely, acid rain and photochemical smog (Roy et al., 2009). Mercury has received great concerns on its influences on both human health and the living environment due to its high toxicity, persistence, and long-distance transport (Chen et al., 2016; Marusczak et al., 2016; Guo et al., 2017). In CFPPs, mercury mainly exists in three forms in the gas streams: elemental mercury (Hg0), oxidized mercury (Hg2+), and particle-bound mercury (Hgp) (Galbreath and Zygarlicke, 2000). Most of Hg2+ and Hgp could be adequately removed by the conventional air pollution control devices. Hg2+ can be removed by wet flue gas desulfurization and Hgp is primarily removed by electrostatic precipitator and fiber filter. However, Hg0 is difficult to be removed due to its high stability and volatility (Zhao et al., 2019).

Instead of using the high-cost activated carbon injection for direct adsorption to transform Hg0 into Hgp (Chou et al., 2018), catalytic oxidation of Hg0 to Hg2+ and subsequently to Hgp over selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalysts could be a co-benefit during traditional NO removal by metal oxide catalysts. Hg0 catalytic oxidation by various metal oxide catalysts in simulated flue gas has also been examined (Wang et al., 2014; Xiong et al., 2017). Some research has also been done on understanding the simultaneous removal of Hg0 and NO (He et al., 2013; Chang et al., 2015; Li et al., 2015; Zhao et al., 2016; Song et al., 2018). The removal effectiveness of Hg0 by the catalysts depends on the operating environment (flue gas composition and temperature) and the properties of the catalysts (Li et al., 2011a). The addition of ammonia for reduction of NOx may inhibit the Hg0 removal due to competition of adsorption sites on the catalyst surface (Chang et al., 2015).

Mn-Ce oxides have been widely studied as low-temperature SCR catalysts due to the presence of various valence states for Mn/Ce and their labile oxygen (Wang et al., 2014). Kang et al. (2006) showed that the NOx conversion of MnOx could keep over 95% at temperature below 175°C; in the same study, Cu-Mn mixed oxides showed over 95% NO removal efficiency at a broader temperature window (50–250°C). Fang et al. (2014) addressed that CuMn2O4 spinel in Cu-Mn mixed oxide catalysts could promote the valence transition between Cu2+ and Mn3+ that promoted the SCR performance. The mixture of metallic species can enhance the effects towards an increment in the mobility of the oxygen, as well as stabilizing the active species and favoring the redox cycles that permits the reactivation of the catalyst (Aguilera et al., 2011). Ce oxide has also been known to have a great oxygen storage capacity and outstanding redox characteristics and can be a promising additive for low-temperature NH3-SCR (Xu et al., 2018). Our earlier studies have also shown that activated carbon and zeolite impregnated with Cu oxide and Cu chloride had great Hg0 adsorption performance (Chiu et al., 2014, 2015; Tsai et al., 2017). Therefore, a combination of Cu-Mn or Cu-Mn-Ce oxides supported by porous materials, such as SiO2, could possess great effectiveness in NO reduction and Hg0 oxidation followed by subsequent adsorption. A summary of selected studies on Cu and Mn oxide catalysts for NO and Hg0 removal is shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Summary of studies on Cu/Mn and other metal oxide catalysts for NO and Hg0 removal.
Table 1. Summary of studies on Cu/Mn and other metal oxide catalysts for NO and Hg0 removal. Table 1. Summary of studies on Cu/Mn and other metal oxide catalysts for NO and Hg0 removal.

The difference in crystallinity, oxidation state, and the amount of specific surface area and pore volume of metal oxides supported by porous materials could influence the NO and Hg0 removal performance. Therefore, a novel silicate exfoliation method was applied in this study to synthesize the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce mixed oxides supported by mesoporous silica. During the silicate exfoliation method, the proper hydrothermal treatment could cause the surface structure of SiO2 to reform. The surface reformation leads to (1) uniform dispersion of metal oxides on the silica surface, (2) a high Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce loading, and (3) large surface area and pore volume, all of which could be highly beneficial for Hg0 adsorption and NO reduction by NH3, but not thoroughly understood by previous research.


Preparation of Metal Oxide-incorporated Mesoporous Silica via Silicate Exfoliation

The CuOx-MnOx/SiO2 samples were prepared by the silicate exfoliation method with a mole ratio of the precursor metal nitrate set at (Cu + Mn)/Si = 1. Firstly, stoichiometric amounts of Cu(NO3)2 and Mn(NO3)2 were dissolved in deionized water. The mixture was then neutralized with Na2CO3 aqueous solution to form the metal template at a proper pH ≈ 10.0 followed by adding the required amounts of sodium silicate solution into the metal salt solution. Then, the mixture was stirred for 2 h at 40°C and hydrothermally treated at 100°C for 3 days. The metal oxide would reconstruct and incorporate with the silicate during the hydrothermal process. After filtration and drying, calcination at 400°C was employed for 3 h in air to yield Cu-Mn samples.

The Ce modification was conducted by adding Ce(NO3)3 (mole ratio: Ce/(Cu + Mn) = 0.1) into the Cu-Mn oxide solution in the first step. Then, the same preparation steps were followed as aforementioned to prepare Cu-Mn-Ce samples. The metal oxides were expected to completely incorporate in the SiO2 samples through the silicate exfoliation method. The samples prepared with different molar ratio were denoted as CuXMnYCeZ (the mole ratio of Cu:Mn:Ce is X:Y:Z). The resulting samples were ground into powder and sieved to 40–60 mesh prior to characterization and NO/Hg0 removal tests. 

Characterization of Metal Oxide-incorporated Mesoporous Silica

The specific surface area (SBET) and total pore volume (Vt) of raw and treated samples were measured by N2 adsorption at 77 K (ASAP 2020, Micromeritics). The surface morphology and particle size was observed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM; JCM-6000Plus, JEOL) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM; JEM-1400; JEOL). The crystalline structures of samples were determined with X-ray diffraction measurement (XRD; XRD-7000S, Shimadzu). The Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR; Spectrum RX1, PerkinElmer) spectra were taken at room temperature and the spectra were recorded in the 2000–500 cm–1 range. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS; ESCALAB 250, VG Scientific) was employed to understand the surface chemical compositions and valence states of metal oxides on the samples. For XPS analysis, all binding energies were referenced to C1s peak at 285 eV. The catalytic properties of resulting samples were characterized by H2 temperature-programmed reduction (H2-TPR) and NH3 temperature-programmed desorption (NH3-TPD) experiments. In H2-TPR and NH3-TPD, samples were firstly pretreated in a pure Ar flow at 150°C. H2-TPR experiments were conducted on a Micromeritics II Autochem 2920 by increasing the temperature to 600°C at a rate of 10 °C min1 with 50 mL min1 of 10% H2/Ar. For NH3-TPD experiments, samples were treated with 10% NH3/Ar for 1 h and then heated up to 750°C at a heating rate of 10 °C min1. The amount of NH3 desorption from samples was detected by the Micromeritics II Autochem 2920.

NO and Hg0 Removal Tests

Fig. 1. Experimental system for fixed-bed Hg0 adsorption breakthrough tests of metal oxide incorporated SiO2 (Chiu et al., 2014).

Hg0 removal performance was examined in a fixed-bed testing apparatus (Fig. 1), similar to our previous study (Chiu et al., 2014), using a simulated flue gas containing 30 µg Nm–3 Hg0. Hg0 was generated with a certified Hg0 permeation tube (VICI Metronics) in a gas generator at specific temperature to ensure a constant Hg0 diffusion rate. 12% CO2, 10% H2O, 6% O2, 50 ppmv HCl, 200 ppmv SO2, 200 ppmv NO, and balanced N2 were applied as the simulated CFPP flue gas condition. The resulting gas was then passed through a temperature-controlled fixed-bed column (i.d.: 0.5ʺ) containing 10 mg sample and 0.5 g quartz sand. The gas flow through an empty column was about 1.5 L min1 at 25°C. The column length of sample/sand mixture was about 1.5 cm, and the time for gas stream to pass the mixture was approximately 0.08 s. The effluent gas from the fixed-bed column was heated by heating tapes and divided into two streams. One stream flowed to an impinger containing SnCl2(aq). SnCl2(aq) was applied to reduce any oxidized Hg compounds to Hg0 to comprehend the adsorption effect of samples; CTHg refers to the total Hg (THg) concentration (i.e., Hg0 + oxidized Hg) in the inlet or outlet stream. The other stream went through an impinger with KCl(aq) with an attempt to completely capture oxidized Hg to understand the oxidation effect to the outlet Hg by the samples; CHg0 represents the Hg0 concentration in the inlet or outlet stream. The Hg0 concentration in the two stream outlets was detected by two individual cold vapor atomic absorption spectrophotometers (CVAAS; EMP-2 coupled with SGM-8 Mercury Monitor, Nippon Instruments Corp.). The experiment was performed for 840 min or ceased when 100% breakthrough was achieved. The Hg adsorption capacities of samples were then calculated based on the breakthrough curves obtained from the CTHg experiment. By determining the difference between the Hg0 concentration monitored by the two spectrophotometers (i.e., CTHg and CHg0), the amount of oxidized Hg in the outlet stream could be estimated. The normalized Hg0 concentration of the THg and Hg0 removal tests and the outlet oxidized Hg ratio were calculated as follows:

where CTHginlet is the concentration of inlet Hg0 (µg Nm3); CTHgoutlet and CHg0outlet are the concentration of outlet Hg0 (µg Nm3) detected by spectrophotometers through the SnCl2 and KCl solution, respectively. Therefore, the Hg0 removal efficiency through adsorption (η) could be determined:

NO removal tests were carried out to determine the optimal mole ratio of Cu/Mn/Ce in the metal oxide-incorporated silica for NO reduction by NH3. The test condition was described as follows: 1 g of sample, 200 ppmv NO, 200 ppmv NH3, 200 ppmv SO2 (when used), 6% O2, and balanced N2 with a total gas flow rate of 1.5 L min1 (25°C) were used. The length of the sample/gas wool mixture in the fixed bed was approximately 5 cm, and the time for the gas flow to pass the mixture was approximately 1 s. NO concentration was continuously monitored with a SICK MAIHAK S710 gas analyzer, which could also monitor the concentration variation of SO2 and O2. The NO concentration at the outlet of reactor was acquired when the NO reduction achieved stability at a given temperature. Because a portion of the downstream NO was captured by the condenser located prior to the flue gas analyzer, the NO removal efficiency was determined by:

where  is the NO concentration obtained from the blank test. The blank test was performed under the simulated condition, without the presence of metal oxide-incorporated SiO2.  is the NO concentration in the outlet gas stream, when the sample is in the fixed-bed reactor.

Based on our preliminary examination, Cu5Mn5, Cu2Mn8, Cu6Mn4Ce1, and Cu8Mn2Ce1 were selected for further investigation to understand the effects of temperature and presence of SO2 due to their better NO removal performance within the tested Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce samples.


Characterization of Cu-Mn
 and Cu-Mn-Ce Incorporated SiO2

The XRD patterns of four samples, including Cu5Mn5, Cu2Mn8, Cu6Mn4Ce1, and Cu8Mn2Ce1 are shown in Fig. 2(a). The broad peak below 30° was denoted as amorphous silica. In addition, no crystalline phase was determined from these patterns. These results suggest that the samples may be amorphous or the metal oxides are highly dispersed on the surface of silica. The weak and broad diffraction peaks at 30.8°, 35°, 57.4°, and 62.4° were attributed to the Cu phyllosilicate in the form of Cu2Si2O5(OH)2 with poor crystallinity. Cu phyllosilicate is the layered structures composed of polymeric sheets of SiO4 tetrahedra linked to sheets of Cu(O,OH)6 octahedra, which are usually divided into 1:1 and 2:1 by layer type (the number of SiO4 tetrahedral layers:the number of metal oxide octahedral layers; Fig. 2(b)). The existence of Cu phyllosilicate phase suggested the formation of monomer species contained Cu-O-Si bridges (Di et al., 2016), which may further polymerize and construct the layer structure of Cu phyllosilicate during the hydrothermal process. Additionally, from the FTIR spectra (Fig. 3), one can clearly see that the copper silicate had a representative absorption band at 1040 cm–1 from the Cu-O-Si stretching smaller than that of the pure silica at 1100 cm–1 from the Si-O-Si stretching (Yue et al., 2013). This decrease in wavelength indicates the formation of the Cu-O-Si bonds in the copper silicate. In this study, the presence of similar structure as described by Di et al. (2016) was also partly supported by the TEM images, presenting as the arrays of nano-sphere and nano-rod structures (Fig. 4), which may be formed due to the inequivalence of the constituent layer of Cu phyllosilicate (Fig. 2(c)).

Fig. 2. (a) XRD patterns of metal-oxide incorporated SiO2; (b) the structures of 1:1 and 2:1 copper phyllosilicate (Di et al., 2016); (c) bonding structure formed in the SiO2 surface by silicate-exfoliation method.Fig. 2. (a) XRD patterns of metal-oxide incorporated SiO2; (b) the structures of 1:1 and 2:1 copper phyllosilicate (Di et al., 2016); (c) bonding structure formed in the SiO2 surface by silicate-exfoliation method.

Fig. 3. FTIR spectra of the (a) Cu-incorporated silicate and (b) pure silica.

Fig. 4. SEM images of the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated silica: (a) Cu5Mn5 × 200; (b) Cu5Mn5 × 1000; (c) Cu6Mn4Ce1 × 200; (d) Cu6Mn4Ce1 × 1000; (e) Cu8Mn2Ce1 × 200; (f) Cu8Mn2Ce1 × 1000.Fig. 4. SEM images of the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated silica: (a) Cu5Mn5 × 200; (b) Cu5Mn5 × 1000; (c) Cu6Mn4Ce1 × 200; (d) Cu6Mn4Ce1 × 1000; (e) Cu8Mn2Ce1 × 200; (f) Cu8Mn2Ce1 × 1000.

Table 2 shows the textural properties of the samples based on the 77 K N2 adsorption. The SBET of the samples was large within 378 and 602 m2 g–1, as compared to approximately 160 m2 g–1 of raw spherical SiO2. The large SBET can be attributed to the uniform framework to form porous structure via the adequate hydrothermal synthesis instead of forming close-packed structure for Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated SiO2. In addition, good dispersion of metal oxides on the silica surface helps avoiding the aggregation of metal oxides on the SiO2 surface to block the pore openings. Therefore, the largest SBET and the arrays of nano-sphere and nano-rod structures were shown on the surface layer of Cu5Mn5 sample (Figs. 4(a), 4(b) and 5(a)), indicating that the Cu/Mn mole ratio = 1 could be the optimal condition to prepare well-dispersed Cu-Mn samples. These experimental results also suggest that the metal oxide layer may contain the Mn-O-Cu bonds to inhibit the metal oxide aggregation. In contrast, Ce oxide modification caused the decrease of SBET and pore volume due to the complicated interactions between these metal species, that may result in mesopore blockage, which are suggested by Figs. 4(c)–4(f), in which the original spherical SiO2 particles disappeared and significant aggregation was shown. Di et al. (2016) also suggested that because copper phyllosilicates possess high specific surface area, the larger surface area of Cu-Mn samples may be attributed to more copper phyllosilicates, or special type of copper phyllosilicate species preserved in the samples.

Table 2. Specific surface area and pore characteristics of metal oxide-incorporated mesoporous silica.

Fig. 5. TEM images of the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated silica: (a) Cu5Mn5; (b) Cu2Mn8; (c) Cu8Mn2Ce1; (d) Cu6Mn4Ce1.Fig. 5. TEM images of the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated silica: (a) Cu5Mn5; (b) Cu2Mn8; (c) Cu8Mn2Ce1; (d) Cu6Mn4Ce1.

Fig. 6 shows the H2-TPR profiles of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce samples. Single metal oxide samples, namely Cu- and Mn-silicates, were also prepared and examined for comparison. The reduction peak centered at 225°C for the Cu-silicate was attributed to two reasons: (1) one-step reduction of low interacting species Cu2+ to Cu0, and (2) partial reduction of highly dispersed species (Cu2+ → Cu+) (Diaz et al., 1999). However, as described by Shi et al. (2018), Cu2+ to Cu0 may not likely occur at our experimental condition. There were two reduction peaks over the Mn-silicate: The peaks under 300°C and above 300°C could be denoted as MnOx species to Mn3O4 and Mn3O4 to MnO, respectively (Shi et al., 2018; Yi et al., 2018). Different from Cu- and Mn-silicate, the broad reduction peak was observed in the results of Cu-Mn samples (except for Cu2Mn8). Yan et al. (2018) proposed that the broad reduction was caused by the synergistic effect, which was related to the electron transfer between Cu and Mn oxides. Furthermore, the trimodal peaks observed over the Cu2Mn8 sample indicated less Cu-Mn interaction on its surface.

Fig. 6. H2-TPR profiles of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated SiO2.Fig. 6. H2-TPR profiles of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated SiO2.

NH3-TPD was carried out to characterize the surface acidity and NH3 adsorption ability (Fig. 7). The desorption peak of Cu5Mn5 at 100°C was denoted as the physically adsorbed NH3. Zheng et al. (2013) proposed that the NH3 desorption peak centered at low temperature (< 400°C) and the peak at high temperature (> 600°C) was assigned to weak acid sites and strong acid sites, respectively. All four samples exhibited the broad peak from 150 to 500°C, ascribed to the multiple desorption NH4+ bound to weak or strong Brønsted acid sites. Different from samples with the addition of Ce, weak desorption peak centered at 600°C originated from Lewis acid sites was observed in the results of Cu5Mn5 and Cu2Mn8. Cu6Mn4Ce1 and Cu2Mn8Ce1 had the similar NH3 desorption profile, which was probably related to the corresponding redox properties and texture. The amounts of desorbed NH3 (without counting the physisorbed NH3) over the four samples followed the sequence: Cu2Mn8 (1.00) > Cu6Mn4Ce1 (0.89) > Cu8Mn2Ce1 (0.68) > Cu5Mn5 (0.52). The reason causing the greatest NH3 adsorption capacity over Cu2Mn8 may be due to the less synergistic effect aforementioned, which influences the surface acid strength. The NH3-TPD results also suggest that Ce could promote the NH3 adsorption capacity, which may be mainly caused by increasing the Brønsted acid sites.

Fig. 7. NH3-TPD profiles of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated SiO2 samples.Fig. 7. NH3-TPD profiles of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated SiO2 samples.

To identify the chemical state of surface species, XPS analysis was carried out over the Cu5Mn5, Cu2Mn8, Cu6Mn4Ce1, and Cu8Mn2Ce1 samples (Figs. 8(a) and 8(b)). The peaks with binding energies corresponding to Cu2p and Mn2p were further deconvoluted. The XPS spectra of Cu2p3/2 could be divided into the Cu+ and Cu2+ peaks at the binding energy of 932.8 and 934.4 eV (Yi et al., 2018) (Fig. 8(a)). According to Fang et al. (2014), Mn2p3/2 could be separated into Mn3+ peak at 641.8–642.0 eV, and Mn4+ peak at 643.2–644.5 eV (Fig. 8(b)). The relative atomic concentration ratios of species are presented in Table 3. For Cu2p XPS results, greater Cu+ ratios were observed in the spectra of Cu5Mn5 and Cu2Mn8; large Mn4+/Mn3+ ratios were observed in the deconvolution results of all samples (Table 3). These experimental results are attributed to the electron transfer between Cu and Mn oxides, which caused the valence transition between Cu2+ and Mn3+.

Fig. 8. (a) Cu2p; (b) Mn2p; (c) O1s; (d) Ce3d XPS spectra of Cu5Mn5, Cu2Mn8, Cu8Mn2Ce1, and Cu6Mn4Ce1 samples.
Fig. 8. (a) Cu2p; (b) Mn2p; (c) O1s; (d) Ce3d XPS spectra of Cu5Mn5, Cu2Mn8, Cu8Mn2Ce1, and Cu6Mn4Ce1 samples. 

Table 3. The relative concentration ratios of specific states of the surface elements on the Cu-Mn-incorporated mesoporous silica.

The XPS spectra of O1s and Ce3d were also analyzed (Figs. 8(c) and 8(d)). There were three different O species on the sample surface: the lattice oxygen (labeled as Oα) at 529.3–530 eV, chemisorbed oxygen (labeled as Oβ) at 531.2–532 eV, and hydroxyl groups, defect oxide, and adsorbed water species (labeled as Oγ) near 540 eV. In addition, the complex spectra of Ce3d could be divided into two different Ce cations. The subbands at 886 eV corresponded to Ce3+; those at 901.5, 907, and 917 eV were attributed to Ce4+. The chemisorbed oxygen was considered as a significant species in the catalytic processes (Yan et al., 2018). Cations with high oxidation state (Ce4+) give rise to a reactive ammonia complex to react with NO (Tang et al., 2016); it resulted in the larger activity over the Cu6Mn4Ce1 compared with the performance over Cu8Mn2Ce1. In addition, the possible reason of high Cu2+/Cu ratio over the Cu8Mn2Ce1 was the valence transition between Ce4+ and Ce3+.

NO Removal Activity of Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce Samples

The NO removal performance of Cu-Mn samples is presented in Fig. 9. Without the presence of Cu oxide, Mn-silicate showed great activity at the temperature range of 200–300°C, with a NO conversion over 90%. However, the NO removal efficiency sharply decreased to 60% with the incorporation of Cu oxides. Corresponding to the H2-TPR, the incorporation of Cu oxide appeared to change the redox properties of Mn-silicate, which caused the inhibition of the SCR activity. Therefore, the greater performance over Cu2Mn8 as compared to other Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce incorporated silica may be due to a lesser influence of the synergistic effect on its Mn-based active sites.

Fig. 9. NO removal efficiency of Cu-Mn incorporated samples as compared to Mn-silicate. Fig. 9. NO removal efficiency of Cu-Mn incorporated samples as compared to Mn-silicate.

The NH3 adsorption capacity of Cu6Mn4Ce1 was similar with that for Cu2Mn8 based on the NH3-TPD results. It is because the high ratio of Ce4+ coordinates with NH3. It was reported that SO2 would occupy the acid sites on the catalyst causing poisoning (Wei et al., 2016); the addition of Ce could trap the sulfation of the active sites (Jin et al., 2014). In order to understand the effect of Ce on limiting SO2 poisoning, Cu2Mn8 and Cu6Mn4Ce1 having large NH3 adsorption ability were selected to evaluate the NO removal efficiency at the temperature range from 150 to 350°C with presence of 200 ppmv SO2 (Fig. 10). The obvious inhibition in NO reduction by SO2 (i.e., 30% decrease in NO removal) was shown over Cu2Mn8. On contrary, there were no obvious decrease in NO removal for Cu6Mn4Ce1; instead, the removal efficiency at 250–350°C was further enhanced. As reported by Jin et al. (2014), the Ce modification causes more Brønsted acid sites, which attribute to the promotion of the SCR performance at 250–350°C. Yang et al. (2013) also showed that CeO2 had an excellent SCR activity in the presence of SO2 at 300–500°C. The promotion of SO2 on the SCR reaction over CeO2 was mainly due to the sulfation of CeO2, which could be the reason for the promotion of NO removal by Cu6Mn4Ce1.

Fig. 10. Effect of SO2 on the NO removal efficiency for (a) Cu2Mn8 and (b) Cu6Mn4Ce1.Fig. 10. Effect of SO2 on the NO removal efficiency for (a) Cu2Mn8 and (b) Cu6Mn4Ce1.

Hg0 Removal Test on Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce Incor
porated Silica

Fig. 11(a) shows the results of THg and Hg0 removal tests over Cu2Mn8 under the baseline condition (i.e., at Hg0 = 30 µg m–3 and 150°C). There was no noticeable difference between CTHg and CHg0 for the 14-h test. The similar results also showed in other three samples, including Cu5Mn5, Cu6Mn4Ce1, and Cu8Mn2Ce1. These experimental results suggest that either the Hg0 catalytic oxidation are not obvious on the sample surface, or, more likely, the oxidized Hg is immediately captured on the surface of the Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce silica samples. Consequently, the Hg0 removal is primarily dependent on the oxidation followed by immediate adsorption. Furthermore, the experimental results also showed that 100% breakthrough was hardly achieved, which may be due to the poor adsorption kinetics between Hg and the tested samples.

Fig. 11. (a) Results of THg and Hg0 removal tests for Cu2Mn8. (b) The average THg removal efficiencies and adsorption capacity over 14-h test for samples at 150°C.Fig. 11. (a) Results of THg and Hg0 removal tests for Cu2Mn8. (b) The average THg removal efficiencies and adsorption capacity over 14-h test for samples at 150°C.

For data comparison, the Hg removal performance was presented as the average THg removal efficiency and the Hg adsorption capacity over 14 h (Fig. 11(b)). The deviation represented the variation of the removal efficiency over the test. The average THg removal efficiency is determined by:

where CTHgoutlet,average is the average Hg0 concentration at the outlet over the THg test. The experimental results for Cu2Mn8 had the greatest average THg removal efficiency, indicating that the effect of Ce modification on enhancing Hg0 adsorption was less significant when Mn was present in a great amount. Notably, Cu6Mn4Ce1 and Cu8Mn2Ce1 had greater average THg removal than Cu5Mn5, indicating that Ce modification enhanced Hg0 adsorption when Mn was present in a smaller amount. Furthermore, the Hg0 adsorption capacity of the tested samples decreased in the same order of acid site content obtained from NH3-TPD data: Cu2Mn8 > Cu6Mn4Ce1 > Cu8Mn2Ce1 > Cu5Mn5. These results, in agreement with previous studies (Chang et al., 2015; Liu et al., 2017), suggest that the amount of the acid sites verified by NH3 adsorption plays an important role in Hg0 oxidation and removal. These results also suggest that the extent of surface area and pore volume should not be the determining factor on Hg0 removal for the tested metal-oxide silica.

Because of its greater NO and Hg0 removal performance as compared to the others, Cu2Mn8 was further tested to evaluate the effect of temperature and inlet concentration on the Hg0 adsorption. The test temperatures were set at 150, 250, and 350°C and the experimental results are shown in Fig. 12(a). Again, the effect of the catalytic oxidation over Cu2Mn8 was not obviously shown in the outlet stream even at 350°C, implying that if Hg oxidation occurs on the surface of Cu-Mn silica, the oxidized Hg would be immediately adsorbed. The average Hg0 removal efficiency decreased with the increase of the temperature. The decrease in THg removal efficiency at 350°C was expected because the adsorption of Hg is thermodynamically unfavorable at elevated temperature (Chiu et al., 2015).

Fig. 12. (a) Temperature dependence of average THg removal efficiency and the adsorption capacity with the inlet Hg0 concentration of 30 µg m–3 for Cu2Mn8. (b) Concentration dependence of average THg removal efficiency and the adsorption capacity at 150°C for Cu2Mn8.Fig. 12. (a) Temperature dependence of average THg removal efficiency and the adsorption capacity with the inlet Hg0 concentration of 30 µg m–3 for Cu2Mn8. (b) Concentration dependence of average THg removal efficiency and the adsorption capacity at 150°C for Cu2Mn8.

The effect of concentration on Hg adsorption over Cu2Mn8 was investigated in the similar gas condition at three inlet Hg0 concentrations: 30, 65, and 100 µg m–3 at 150°C (Fig. 12(b)). Again, oxidized Hg was not observed in the outlet stream even as the inlet Hg0 was at 100 µg m3. The greatest THg removal efficiency was observed when the inlet Hg0 increased to 65 µg m3. The largest adsorption capacity was obtained when the inlet Hg0 concentration increased to 100 µg m3.

Because of the complex composition of the simulated coal-combustion flue gas, the transient response test was further performed on Cu2Mn8 to investigate the effect of flue gas components on Hg0 adsorption at 150°C. Fig. 13(a) shows the effect of pure N2, 6% O2, 12% CO2, and 200 ppmv NO on Hg0 adsorption. Firstly, there was only 10% THg removal efficiency for Cu2Mn8 in pure N2 condition. It is related to the reaction of Hg0 with a limited amount of lattice oxygen, which may follow the Mars-Massen mechanism (Qiao et al., 2009). Hg0 firstly adsorbed on the surface to form Hg0(ad). The Hg0(ad) then bonded with the lattice oxygen on the samples to form HgO(ad). The uptake of the lattice oxygen by Hg would be compensated by chemisorbed oxygen due to the high mobility.

Fig. 13. (a) Transient response test on Cu2Mn8 sample. (b) Hg0 adsorption and oxidation test for Cu2Mn8 pretreated with 50 ppmv HCl.Fig. 13. (a) Transient response test on Cu2Mn8 sample. (b) Hg0 adsorption and oxidation test for Cu2Mn8 pretreated with 50 ppmv HCl.

With the addition of 6% O2 at 4.5 h, the Hg0 removal efficiency increased slightly (Fig. 13(a)) because the gas-phase oxygen would replenish the uptake of the lattice oxygen and chemisorbed oxygen. At around 5.8 h, 12% CO2 was introduced and there was no significant difference. Then, 200 ppmv NO was added in at 6 h. The THg removal efficiency increased to 25% and small amount of oxidized Hg was observed at the outlet. NO could be adsorbed on the basic sites of metal-oxide catalysts and give rise to active species, such as NO2 and NO2+ for Hg oxidation. Li et al. (2011b) also suggested the oxidized Hg detected at the outlet was some volatile mercuric compounds, such as Hg(NO3)2.

Following the test, 50 ppmv HCl was added in at 9 h (Fig. 13(a)). The THg and Hg0 removal efficiency sharply increased to 80 and 95%, respectively. The high Hg oxidation by HCl, which may stem from formation of HgCl2, has been proposed by several studies (Presto and Granite, 2006; Wang et al., 2014). Therefore, further investigation for better understanding the enhancing behavior of Hg0 adsorption by HCl at 150°C was done on Cu2Mn8, shown in Fig. 13(b). Firstly, the Cu2Mn8 sample was pretreated with 50 ppmv HCl for 1 h and purged with N2 for 0.5 h; then, 30 µg m–3 Hg0 carried by N2 was applied to the HCl-pretreated sample. The THg removal efficiency was shown to slowly decrease from 55 to 35% for 7 h. Consequently, HCl was confirmed to be strongly adsorbed on the surface of Cu2Mn8 and further oxidized and captured Hg0. At 7 h, the addition of oxygen, as mentioned above, replenished the deficiency of the surface oxygen that further enhanced the Hg0 adsorption again.

According to the transient response and HCl pretreatment test, the adsorbed HCl is confirmed to play the dominant role in the Hg0 oxidation/adsorption over the Cu-Mn samples. HCl would be adsorbed on the surface through two pathways (He et al., 2009; Chang et al., 2015): (1) The adsorbed HCl on the original basic sites of Cu-Mn samples would modify the chemical environments of samples, which caused the shift of the valence due to the strong electronegativity of Cl (Eq. (5)), and (2) the adsorbed HCl could bond with neighboring sites (Eq. (6)).


where M could be Mn or Cu in this study.

Based on the aforementioned results, the Hg0 removal mechanism may be explained by the Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanism:

Because of a low energy barrier in the reaction between Hg and Cl, the probable reactions would occur between reactive Cl and Hg0 on the surface of samples (Presto and Granite, 2006). First, HCl would adsorb on the surface basic sites and generate the reactive Cl. The low ratios of Cu2+/Cu and high ratios of Mn4+/Mn in the XPS results indicate that the probable sites are Cu+, which is activated by the reactive Cl, and Mn4+ would bond with HCl. Furthermore, the correspondence between the results of the NH3-TPD and the Hg0 removal test suggest that the acid sites, both the Brønsted and Lewis acid sites, could be the activated Cl species. Then, the adsorbed Hg0 would react with the reactive Cl to form HgCl2, which is quickly adsorbed by the samples. The reoxidation of the Mn3+–OH species by oxygen replenishes Mn4+=O. Notably, Hg0 oxidation may also follow the Eley-Rideal mechanism (Xiong et al., 2017), for which gaseous Hg0 directly reacts with the adsorbed reactive Cl to form HgCl2 and the formed HgCl2 are mostly released back to the gas phase and leads to significant Hg0 oxidation in the outlet stream. This may not be the case observed in our experiments because most of the formed oxidized Hg are speculated to adsorb on the sample surface.

The transient response test implied that the THg removal efficiency could achieve over 95% with the flue gas condition without the presence of SO2 and H2O vapor. Therefore, the effect of SO2 was further investigated (Fig. 14). The results showed that the Hg0 oxidation kept over 90%, but the Hg capture efficiency gradually decreased from 80 to 60%. These experimental results indicate that the competitive adsorption between the possibly formed HgCl2 and SO2 did not inhibit the Hg0 oxidation, but the oxidized Hg is less adsorptive, and a portion of it is released into the outlet stream. H2O has also been reported to inhibit Hg0 oxidation and removal over metal or metal oxide based catalysts due to the competitive adsorption with reactive species, which caused the decrease of the overall Hg0 oxidation efficiency (Li et al., 2011b).

Fig. 14. Effect of 200 ppmv SO2 on Hg0 oxidation and adsorption for Cu2Mn8 sample.Fig. 14. Effect of 200 ppmv SO2 on Hg0 oxidation and adsorption for Cu2Mn8 sample.


We hydrothermally exfoliated silicate to create mesoporous SiO2 with a large specific surface area and well-dispersed Cu-Mn and Cu-Mn-Ce oxides. The presence of Cu phyllosilicate, detected via XRD, in the SiO2 indicated that the constituent layer contained Cu-O-Si bonds that had formed during the exfoliation, resulting in the formation of nano-sphere and nano-rod structures, which were observed in TEM images. The transfer of valences between Cu2+ and Mn3+ led to the single reduction peak displayed in the TPR profiles and the high Mn4+/Mn and Cu+/Cu ratios observed via XPS. Synergistic effects inhibited the NO removal efficiency of the Cu-Mn silica. However, incorporating Ce enhanced the catalyst’s resistance to SO2 poisoning and increased its adsorption of NH3, thereby promoting the reduction of NO. Hg0 was primarily removed via adsorption for the Cu-Mn as well as the Cu-Mn-Ce silica. Based on transient response experiments, the main reactions occurred between the adsorbed HCl and the surface of the silica, resulting in the formation of reactive Cl, which led to the oxidation, followed by the immediate adsorption, of Hg0


This study was financially supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan (MOST 103-2622-E-002-038-CC3).


The authors declare no competing financial interest.

Don't forget to share this article 


Subscribe to our Newsletter 

Aerosol and Air Quality Research has published over 2,000 peer-reviewed articles. Enter your email address to receive latest updates and research articles to your inbox every second week.

Latest coronavirus research from Aerosol and Air Quality Research

2018 Impact Factor: 2.735

5-Year Impact Factor: 2.827

SCImago Journal & Country Rank

Aerosol and Air Quality Research (AAQR) is an independently-run non-profit journal, promotes submissions of high-quality research, and strives to be one of the leading aerosol and air quality open-access journals in the world.