Cite this article: Busby, B.D., Ward, T.J., Turner, J.R. and Palmer, C.P. (2016). Comparison and Evaluation of Methods to Apportion Ambient PM2.5 to Residential Wood Heating in Fairbanks, AK.
Aerosol Air Qual. Res.
16: 492-503. https://doi.org/10.4209/aaqr.2015.04.0235
A quantitative comparison of wood smoke source apportionment methods is presented.
Wood smoke apportionments via levoglucosan or 14C methods give consistent results.
The chemical mass balance approach overestimates wood smoke portion in Fairbanks.
Suggested ratios of wood smoke PM2.5 to levoglucosan range from 9 to 13.3.
New wood smoke PM2.5 to levoglucosan ratios are consistent with previous reports.
Biomass burning for residential heating significantly contributes to ambient PM2.5 burdens in many areas, making source apportionment to wood heater emissions an important issue. This study compares and evaluates Chemical Mass Balance (CMB), levoglucosan analysis, and 14C analysis methods for apportionment. Results suggest that the CMB method appears to overestimate the contribution of residential wood heating in Fairbanks, perhaps due to non-representativeness of emissions source profiles. Carbon-14 analysis allows for apportionment to biomass sources, but must be corrected for non-carbon PM2.5 content. Levoglucosan analysis has the advantage of being relatively inexpensive, but there is considerable uncertainty in determining conversion factors to calculate wood smoke levels from measured levoglucosan concentrations. Conversion factors in the range of 9.1 to 13.3 are calculated from previously published and experimental mass fractions of levoglucosan in wood smoke PM2.5. Conversion factors in the range of 10.7 to 12.9 are determined from analysis of independent field measurements of 14C and levoglucosan in Fairbanks. The calculated and measured conversion factors are consistent and are similar to previously-reported values. The three apportionment methods (focused on residential wood smoke contributions) are complementary and collectively provide a means to evaluate or confirm apportionment results.
Keywords: Wood smoke; Levoglucosan; Source apportionment; Chemical mass balance; Carbon-14
Aerosol and Air Quality Research (AAQR) is an independently-run non-profit journal, promotes submissions of high-quality research, and strives to be one of the leading aerosol and air quality open-access journals in the world.